Bethany Office Staff
Cindy Brandon, Head of School
Mrs. Brandon has been with BCS for 26 years. During most of that time, she has served in our Middle School, teaching ELA and Literature. All four of Mrs. Brandon’s children have attended Bethany Christian School and she is excited to now see her grandkids walking through the hallways. Mrs. Brandon has served as our vice principal for the past eight years. Because of the school board’s confidence in her administrative, educational and spiritual leadership abilities, Mrs. Brandon was appointed to Head of School in the fall of 2026.
Cassie McKinley
Secretary
Roxie Rust
Finance & Marketing
Karen Brenneman
Learning Support
Bethany Faculty & Staff Directory
Preschool & Elementary School
Pre-K 3: Patty Reed— preed@bethanychristian.org
Pre-K 4: Jessica Sexton— jsexton@bethanychristian.org
Kindergarten: Missy Baker— mbaker@bethanychristian.org
1st Grade: Daisey Ingiosi— dingiosi@bethanychristian.org
2nd Grade: Adrienne Fiscus— afiscus@bethanychristian.org
3rd Grade: Sue Hancock— shancock@bethanychristian.org
4th Grade: Jeannette McCullough— jmccullough@bethanychristian.org
5th Grade: Aubree Smith— asmith@bethanychristian.org
Middle School
Bible & Social Studies: Norman McCoy— nmccoy@bethanychristian.org
Math: Susan Smith— ssmith@bethanychristian.org
English & Literature: Jennifer White— jwhite@bethanychristian.org
Science & M.S. P.E: Brenda Smith— bsmith@bethanychristian.org
Specials
Music: LeeAnne McCoy— lmccoy@bethanychristian.org
Art: Carolyn Heisler— heislercarolyn@gmail.com
P.E. & Tech: Aubree Smith— asmith@bethanychristian.org
Library: Leighann McGovern-Borgis—
Resource Room: Colleen Terranova—
Bethany Christian School Board
Bethany Christian School is a board run school. The members of the board are appointed by Bethany Presbyterian Church and is comprised of faithful leaders and members of the church. The Bethany Christian School Board provides spiritual and mission-focused governance for Bethany Christian School, ensuring the school remains faithful to its Christian and Reformed foundation.
The Role of the School Board:
Preserves the doctrinal teaching of the Reformed Faith
Promotes Christ-like conduct and spiritual growth in the school community
Oversees school governance, promotion, and financial support
Safeguards the school’s mission to glorify God, teach from a Christian and Reformed worldview, lead children toward faith in Jesus Christ, and support parents in raising responsible children
Parents who wish to communicate with the School Board may do so by email.